Restaurants | Sharon & Hermitage – The Metro Monthly Dining Guide covers restaurants in the Youngstown-Warren area, Columbiana, western Pennsylvania. For changes, corrections or suggestions, email
re*********@me**********.net
or call 330-259-0435.
Restaurants | Sharon
Aldo’s Pizza, Pasta, Italian Specialties Pizza, Italian. 1440 E. State St., Sharon 16146. 724-342-8220. Pizza, pasta, Italian specialties. Pizza by the slice, pepperoni rolls, stromboli, Philly steak, hot and cold subs, garlic rosemary roasted chicken, Napoletana (New York-style round), Sicilian (square pan, thick crust), extra thick (Chicago-style, round), gourmet and stuffed pizzas, appetizers, soups, salads, Italian desserts. LD.
Apollo Maennerchor Club German social club, beer. 391 S. Dock St., Sharon 16146. 724-308-6599. Social club dating from the 1870s features German food and beer. Full bar. Live music. LD.
The Block by Nova Destinations Various. 23 Chestnut Ave., Sharon 16146. 724-979-4004. www.nova.wine. Complex offers five themed restaurants, including the Bluttered Bloke (Irish pub: bangers and mash, Reubens, Irish stew, fish and chips); Das Boot (German beer hall: Jagerschnitzel, Oktoberfest burger, wurst platter, appetizers); Emerald Seahorse (tiki lounge: Polynesian food (tuna poke, pork teriyaki, Ahi tuna salad, cocktails and mocktails); Cantina de los Muertos (Spanish cantina: steak chimichurri, chicken tostada, seafood paella for two. Sangria and tequila-based drinks); and Lost & Found (speakeasy/mostly Italian: focaccia, Calabrese sausage, Angus burger, chicken and seafood). Prohibition-themed drinks and cocktails. Menus.
Croakers Brewing Company Tap room, craft beers, brewhouse. 74 N. Sharpsville Ave., Sharon 16146. 724-202-7808. croakersbrew.com. Tap room serves locally produced craft beers, small selection of craft cocktails. Beers are brewed in Union Township near New Castle. Menu.
Domino’s Pizza. Pizza. 869 E. State St., Sharon 16146. 724-347-3020. Menu. LD.
Donna’s Diner American, classic diner. 10 W. State St., Sharon 16146. 724-346-7373. donnas-diner.com…. Stainless steel diner serves classic diner food. Breakfast (all day), appetizers, salads, sandwiches, burgers, dinners, shakes, malts, ice cream treats. Menu. BLD.
Elephant #8. Thai cuisine. 52 N. Sharpsville Ave., Sharon 16146. 724-979-4148. elephantnumber8.com…. Lunch and dinner specials. Soups, salads, curries, pad thai, fried rice, noodle stir fries, house specialties and Thai curries. (Website only lists Slippery Rock location.) Menu. LD.
Firebean Espresso Cafe, coffee, baked goods. 154 E. State St., Sharon 16146. 330-509-4467. Specialty coffees with a large variety of flavors, teas, Italian sodas, smoothies, shakes and baked goods. BL.
Giovanni’s Pizza, Homestyle Italian. 1354 E. State St., Sharon 724-308-6817. Pepperoni rolls, pizza, salads, pasta, hot and cold subs, burgers, pasta. LD.
Haitian Sensation Haitian, cafe, smoothies, coffee. 76 Shenango Ave., Sharon 724-983-5318. haitiansensationcoffee.com…. Caribbean specialties include pulled pork, beef, fish, chicken sandwiches, Haitian macaroni and cheese, rice and beans (beef, chicken, pork), beef stew, jerk chicken, ox tails, goat, fried plantains, desserts (banana cake, bread pudding, chocolate coconut cake). Menu. LD.
J.J.’s Litehouse American, delicatessen. 971 Division St., Sharon 16146. 724-346-3021. jjslitehouse.com. Soups, appetizers, hot and cold sandwiches, flatbreads, pasta, chicken, veal, beef, seafood, burgers, wraps. House specialties include prime rib, a pressed-steak sandwich, and hand-dipped smelts. Menu. LD.
Keg Bar & Grille American, pub style. 1499 E. State St., Sharon 16146. 724-347-2757. facebook.com… Wings, appetizers, burgers, hot and cold sandwiches, Italian pressed steak. Friday fish dinners and sandwiches. Since 1967. Live music, patio seating. Full bar. LD.
Julian’s Bar & Grill New American, pub style. 234 E. State St., Sharon 16146. 724-979-4090. Croissants, pita tacos, wraps, melts, salads, burgers, pasta, steak, fish, vegetarian. Artistic presentation. Live music. Craft cocktails. Full bar. LD.
Marco’s Pizza. Pizza. 1140 E. State St., Sharon 16146. 724-981-2826. Pizza, subs, salads, sides. Menu. LD.
McCall’s Chicken & Ribs Southern-style barbecue. 810 S. Irvine Ave., Sharon 16146. 724-979-4001. Roasted and fried chicken, barbecue rib dinners, sandwiches, catfish, wing dings, candied yams, greens, roasted potatoes, macaroni and cheese, cornbread. LD.
New Main Moon Chinese. 84 W. Connelly Blvd., Sharon 16146. 724-347-2272. Appetizers, soups, fried rice, lo mein, lunch, combinations (beef, pork, chicken, shrimp, bean curd). LD.
Niko and Lou’s Coney Island American, homestyle, Greek. 44 W. State St., Sharon 16146. 724-347-4448. Breakfast, coneys, burgers, gyros, entrees, chili. BLD.
Nittany Pub & Grille American, pub style. 665 Thornton Ave., Sharon 16146. 724-346-9072. Soups, salads, burgers, sandwiches (shaved beef, po’ boys, Reubens, pressed steak, Philly steak), wings, wraps, melts. Full bar. LD.
Our Gang’s Lounge Pub style, American, wings. 93 N. Sharpsville Ave., Sharon 16146. 724-342-9902. Wings (nearly too many varieties to count), sandwiches, burgers, sides. Full bar. LD.
Pizza Joe’s. Pizza, sandwiches. 52 S. Water Ave., Sharon 16146. 724-342-2500. Pizza (round and square varieties), toasted-bun subs (hot and cold), wedgies (sandwiches made with round pizza shells), calzones, stromboli, salads. Menu. LD.
Quaker Steak and Lube Wings, burgers, classic American. 101 Chestnut St., Sharon 16146. 724-981-WING. thelube.com…. Classic American restaurant with automotive theme. The original location! Wings, sandwiches, burgers, salads, sides. Signature hard lemonades, margaritas, cocktails, bottled and draft beer. Full bar. Menu. LD.
Sharon Hot Dog Shop American, diner style. 134 W. State St., Sharon 16146. 724-346-3691. Authentic Hellenic diner. Home-style food, hot dogs, gyros. Breakfast, sandwiches, dinner platters. BLD.
Tony’s Pizza & Pub Pizza, Italian. 628 Stambaugh Ave., Sharon 16146. 724-347-3323. Pizza, sandwiches (steak, sausage, roast beef), Italian sub, calzones, pepperoni rolls, wings, fish sandwiches on Friday. Menu. LD.
Restaurants | Hermitage
Bob Evans American, homestyle. 115 S. Hermitage Road, Hermitage 16148. 724-342-7307. bobevans.com…. Homestyle breakfast, lunch, traditional and contemporary dinners. Menu. BLD.
Buffalo Wild Wings American, sports bar. 3100 Shenango Valley Freeway, Hermitage 16148. Sports-bar atmosphere. Appetizers, wings, burgers, sandwiches, wraps. Full bar. Menu. LD.
China Wok Chinese. 2425 E. State St., Hermitage 16148. 724-981-8168. chinawokhermitage.com. Soup, appetizers, chow mein, lo mein, fried rice, poultry, beef, pork, shrimp, vegetable entrees. Lunch specials, dinner combinations. Menu. LD.
Chipotle Mexican Grill Mexican. 125 N. Hermitage Road, Hermitage 16148. chipotle.com…. 724-308-3026. Made-to-order burritos, burrito bowls, “lifestyle” bowls (keto, high protein, plant-based), quesadillas, salads, tacos, children’s meals. Beef, chicken, pork and vegetarian. Menu. LD.
Combine Brothers Bar & Grille Traditional and contemporary Italian. 2376 S. Hermitage Road, Hermitage 16148. 724-983-1057. combinebrothers.com…. Family-owned independent serves traditional and contemporary Italian. Appetizers, pizza, salads, sandwiches, signature pastas. The rolls are light, yeasty and nearly as big as softballs. Family and kid-friendly. Full bar. Menu. LD.
Eat’n Park American, contemporary diner style. 2270 E. State St., Hermitage 16148. 724-342-1383. Breakfast, burgers, salads, sandwiches, dinner entrees (diner classics and contemporary). Soup, salad and fruit bar. Saturday breakfast buffet, Sunday brunch. Menu. BBrLD.
El Vallarta Mexican Restaurant & Cantina Mexican. 3101 E. State St., Hermitage 16148. 724-981-7000. Appetizers, shrimp cocktail, salads, street tacos, quesadillas, fajitas, enchiladas, burritos, combination dinners, house specialties. Full bar. Menu. LD.
Four Star Pizza Pizza, Italian. 1119 Mercer Ave., Hermitage 16148. 724-418-4693. Pizza, subs, stromboli, pizza rolls, wings, salads, sides. LD.
Golden Corral Buffet & Grill Buffet, American. 1025 N. Hermitage Road, Hermitage 16148. 724-347-2503. goldencorral.com…. Extensive breakfast, lunch and dinner buffets with multiple stations. Menu. BLD.
Hermitage Familia’s Restaurant and Hot Dog Hut Coneys, homestyle. 1628 E. State St., Hermitage 16148. 724-981-4530. hermitagehotdoghut.com…. LD.
Hickory Grille American. 1645 N. Hermitage Road, Hermitage 16159. 724-962-1775. springfields.com… Part of the Springfield Grille collection of restaurants. Classic, contemporary. Appetizers, flatbreads, sandwiches, crab cakes, burgers, salads, pasta, steak, ribs, seafood. Full bar. Menu. LD.
Hot Head Burritos Mexican. 3362 E. State St., Hermitage 16148. 724-979-4763. hotheadburritos.com…. Burritos, bowls, chicken, steak and vegetable power bowls, keto and paleo bowls. Build-your-own bowls, burritos, tacos, quesadillas and nachos. Menu. LD.
Hot Rods Sub Shop Sub sandwiches, lunch. 2923 E. State St. #2748, Hermitage 16148. 724-346-6420. Over 30 varieties of toasted submarine sandwiches, plus soups, salads, flatbreads and wraps. LD.
Jai-Alai American, pub style. 1109 Mercer Ave., Hermitage 16148. 724-346-1666. Appetizers, sides, soups, salads, burgers, wings, hot and cold sandwiches. Signature cocktails. Full bar. LD.
Kobe Japanese Restaurant & Sushi Bar Japanese, hibachi, sushi. 2499 E. State St., Hermitage 16148. 724-981-9955. kobejr.com…. Hibachi-style grill, sushi menu. LD.
La Isla Mexican Restaurant Mexican. 1800 E. State St., Hermitage 16148. 724-342-7674. Burritos, enchiladas, chimichangas, fajitas, dinner combinations, traditional house specialties, a la carte lunches, combinations. Chicken, beef, pork, seafood, vegetarian. Mexican sodas, domestic and imported beers, margaritas, daiquiris. Full bar. LD.
Mobogo Asian Cuisine Vietnamese, pho, Asian. 1656 E. State St., Hermitage 16148. 724-308-7035. Egg rolls, spring rolls, Vietnamese crepes, pho (soups) with vermicelli noodles, charbroils (pork, chicken, shrimp and grilled pork), udon noodle stir-fries, japchae (sweet-potato noodle) served with beef, pork, chicken or shrimp, bubble teas. LD.
Nick’s Inn 62 Pub food, traditional American. 1890 E. State St., Hermitage 16148. 724-346-4546. Soups, salads, sides, wings, sandwiches, burgers, pasta, seafood, home-style entrees. Bar, table and booth seating. Full bar. LD.
Panera Bread American, delicatessen, baked goods. 2390 E. State St., Hermitage 16148. 724-346-6242. Counter service and pickup. Coffee, baked goods, soups, salads, sandwiches, desserts. Booth, table and patio seating. BLD.
Pita a Sandwich Shop. Sandwiches. 2560 E. State St., Hermitage 16148. 724-658-4787.gopitago.com…. Gyros, pita sandwiches (meat and vegetarian varieties), fresh-cut fries, juices. Menu. LD.
Plaza Pizza Italian, pizza. 2419 E. State St., Hermitage 16148. 724-981-0634. LD.
Red Lobster Seafood, American. 3370 Shenango Valley Freeway, Hermitage 16148. 724- 342-1788. redlobster.com…. Signature seafood items, grilled sirloin, bowls, sandwiches, pasta, soup, salads, cheddar biscuits, desserts. Full bar. Menu. LD.
Scotto’s Famous Pizza Pizza, Italian. 2090 E. State St., Hermitage 16148. 724-342-0100. scottospizzahermitage.com. Pizza, wings, subs, stromboli, salads, appetizers. Chicago-style (deep dish), New York (thin), Sicilian (square). LD.
Smoky Martin’s BBQ Barbecue, American. 3601 E. State St., Hermitage 16148. smokymartinsbbq.com… Barbecue (pulled pork, brisket, baby back ribs, full racks, platters), smoked half chickens, wood-fired pizzas, wings, turkey sandwiches, brisket chili with corn bread, loaded baked potatoes, desserts (Belgian waffle with ice cream), strawberry shortcake, apple dumpling, peach cobbler). Menu. LD.
Starbucks American, coffee, cafe. Hermitage Square, 3342 E. State St., Hermitage 16148. 724-981-5836. Specialty coffees, teas, pastries, cookies and baked goods. Menu. BLD.
Tops Buffet Chinese, buffet. Hermitage Hills Plaza, 2980 E. State Road, Hermitage 16148. 724-346-7788. LD.
Valley Kitchen American, contemporary homestyle. 3640 E. State St., Hermitage 16148. 724- 308-6262. Large, rustic dining room with exposed ceiling joists and striking industrial features. Serves breakfast and lunch. Omelets, waffles, chicken and waffles, scrambles, country fried steak, flat iron steak and eggs, pancakes, French toast, corned beef hash, skillets, eggs Benedict, and lighter items like fruit and yogurt parfaits, granola bowls and avocado toast. The lunch side includes hot and cold sandwiches, salads, smashburgers and various sides. Booth, table and bar/counter seating. BL.
Vey’s Pub & Grille American, pub style. 3176 E. State St., Hermitage 16148. 724-308-6167. Appetizers (boneless wings, edamame, coconut shrimp, cheese plate, pot stickers, steak (steak tips, flat iron, sirloin, filet, New York Strip), fish, chops, pasta, burgers, hot and cold sandwiches. Full bar. Menu. LD.
Nearby
Stonewall’s Tavern American, casual, pub style. 2844 Lake Road, Clark, Pa. 16113. 724-962-2992. Located at Tara – a Country Inn. Rustic stone tavern serves appetizers, pasta, baby back ribs, steaks, seafood, chicken, veal. Desserts. Beer, wine, cocktails. Full bar. D.
Atlanta Lounge American, Wine Spector’s “Award of Excellence.” 2844 Lake Road, Clark, Pa. 16113. 724-962-2992. Located at Tara – a Country Inn. Luxurious, dark paneled bar has an antebellum theme. House drinks include hot cider and rum, mimosas, craft cocktails, non-alcoholic cider, and specialty martinis. The award-winning wine list includes over 100 vintages. Beer, wine, cocktails. Full bar. D.
Metro Monthly is a local news and events magazine based in Youngstown, Ohio. We circulate throughout the Mahoning Valley and offer print and online editions. Be sure to visit our publication’s website for news, features, local history, and the Metro Monthly Calendar. Office: 330-259-0435.
© 2024 Metro Monthly. All rights reserved.
